Sunday, April 17, 2011

The Crux of the C-USA lawsuit

ESPN's lawsuit against Conference USA is ongoing and according to the court system, a pretrial hearing will be held on June 1st, 2011 in Manhattan.   Much of this entry is word for word what I posted on NCAABBS.com's C-USA board.

In ESPN's complaint, linked here (the zip file contains their complaint and the existing C-USA/ESPN contract), they detail a series of communications between commissioner Britton Banowsky and Burke Magnus, ESPN's collegiate sports division executive.

As a general summary, and again this is ESPN's timeline, a deal was close to being executed in June. They continued to work through the fall, then in late December C-USA presented an offer that was drastically different that the "Ten Points" they had been discussing (must be the framework of a deal). ESPN's complaint guesses that the C-USA BoD had soured on weeknight football.

ESPN's complaint revolves around the First Offer/First Refusal clause. According to the complaint, C-USA properly followed up after the exclusive negotiation window expired (which was mutually extended twice from the end of April until before Memorial Day 2010) within three days with an email as part of the negotiation that included a rights fee that C-USA was willing to live with ($22.5 million for five years). ESPN contends that this email was not an official first offer as part of the clause, even though the correspondence was sent within the three day time frame.

From there, because ESPN doesn't consider the correspondence an official "First Offer" and ESPN believes they didn't provide a "First Refusal", C-USA's rights should have not been negotiated with a third party (FOX).

Key thing about this lawsuit is that while ESPN is fighting to protect their own contractual rights, this suit will be watched by all sports rightsholders as a matter of contract law.  Depending on how this case goes, or is settled, expect lawyers to stipulate even further how a written offer should be constituted.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

MWC 2011 Television Schedule Released, CBS College Sports Filling Their Schedule

The MWC released its 2011 television schedule today, so it seems like all is set with existing television partner CBS Sports Network, along with secondary partner Comcast.  I say Comcast is a secondary partner because they don't actually own any MWC football rights.  They've gained clearance to air games as the owner of the mtn., plus through sublicensing games on Versus.

Anyways the schedule looks about the same as prior seasons, though there is one less game on CBS Sports Network than compared to previous years.  With each team carrying one more non-conference game and in some cases having to fill the game with a 2nd FCS team or an away game, CBS didn't have quite the picks they used to.  Also the mtn. is carrying a few more games vs. FCS teams than they have in the past.  It allows them to maintain a schedule of 30 games, which is right around what they've carried in prior year.  One item that is new is a Friday night game on CBS Sports Network, something the conference has not done with the network.  They have played games on Fridays, but most were on Black Friday and the other game traditionally is played on a Friday (Utah St.-BYU).

With the games in place, CBS Sports Network is beginning to flesh its schedule out.  Assuming that all Army games will kickoff at 12pm and Navy games at 3:30pm, it leaves likely around 15-18 games that C-USA could fill on the network, plus eight MWC games.  In the case of the C-USA schedule, it depends on what games FOX Sports wants to air and whether any C-USA games will air in 12pm slots that could be available for the eastern time zone schools.

Saturday, April 2, 2011

Random Items for 4/2/11

Just spitballin'.  Not throwing the #Fastball.
  • Have to say that I was extremely impressed with the CBS/Turner arrangement for the NCAA men's tournament. Although I did not see any TV from the Friday-Sunday games of the 1st weekend (was at Quicken Loans arena for games there), I was impressed on how well the talent was able to let the viewer know where to find a close game and how well Turner talent meshed with the CBS talent when the crews were mixed both courtside and in the studio.  The online aspect of the tournament was improved as well with Turner providing more social networking features to the March Madness On Demand product.  I'm sure there are items that they would like to improve, but it was a great first run.

  • Still waiting on a fair amount of early season college football telecast information
    • Big East - Marshall at West Virginia & Wake Forest at Syracuse were designated as games that could move to another date during the 1st week of the season.  Thursday & Friday night are still open for ESPN, and I'm told one of the games is likely to be moved to Sunday
    • Big 12 - The conference has still not made its schedule official as games are expected to be moved to Championship Saturday and to Thursday nights.  One article notes fans are getting restless as they want to start prepping for road trips and plan for lodging & transportation, particularly airfare which increases by the day.
    • C-USA - Besides the likely Miss St.-Memphis Thursday night opener, FOX Sports Media Group & CBS College Sports are finalizing their schedules.  Does not look like games will be selected on a 12 day basis.  More on C-USA later as they have other rights issues
    • MWC - I expect that their TV schedule is in flight.  Likely being decided in tandem with the C-USA schedule for CBS College Sports, with select games on Versus.
    • WAC - When the schedule was announced, it was said that additional telecasts would be selected as only one has so far (Boise St. at Fresno St.).  There are other games on the schedule that are worthy for TV, just depends whether they'll be in season selections or if ESPN will move games to weeknights.  With the WAC expecting a severe rights fee and appearance cut, there might only be 2-3 more ESPN/ESPN2 appearances.
    • Service academies - In the same boat as other conferences tied to CBS College Sports.  Only item we're waiting on is the kickoff time 
  • Regardless of whether you like that C-USA signed a deal with FOX Sports for their telecast rights and/or you feel ESPN wronged the conference while they were a rightsholder, we have to be mindful of the legal issues surrounding ESPN's lawsuit against the conference.  ESPN has their opinion of what went down, so does C-USA.  Its possible that either side could be wrong and we have to let that run its course.  I do believe competition is good and I don't believe that ESPN is suing to directly damage FOX in any way.  FOX will become involved, likely to establish timelines of negotiations and probably to protect the agreement that ESPN has requested to be voided.

  • Fantastic move by NBC to convince Notre Dame to move their home game vs. USC to a night game.  First on-campus night game since 1990 vs. Michigan.  Arguably the marquee Notre Dame home game this year.  I know that the administration there does not like to do night games due to possible crowd/tailgating issues.  Looking over the available games for ABC, that might be better than anything that they can offer for Saturday night.

  • Larry Scott has been monitoring the NFL lockout and has thought about moving games to Sundays in the event the lockout reaches September.  Some conferences this works better than others.  I believe all conferences have had discussions about this, possibly in conjunction of setting television schedules. CBS might be an SEC rightsholder, but I don't think it works for their conference due to the traveling nature of most fan bases.  Might work with the Pac-12 or the Big East, though with so many weeknight games in the Big East already, it might not work either.  Small conferences might be a worthy target, for the right price, but I think those decisions need to be made now.  Not in August.

  • With Pac-12 rights for 2012-13 and beyond on the open market, we'll see whether Comcast & Turner, or maybe another unknown party, will challenge FOX or ESPN for existing rights.  If its true that the conference wants to consolidate their rights under a single partner, that might leave Turner or ESPN out.  Don't count out ESPN though.  They might not be able to offer as many timeslots on ABC or the various ESPN networks, but they have a solid digital platform and by starting up the Texas network, they'll be able to discuss their ability to do a Pac-12 network.  Like others, I do believe that FOX is still likely to offer most of what the Pac-12 wants.

  • F/X moving back into sports programming, particularly college sports, is a welcome move.  The network televised games from the Big 12, Pac-10 and Conference USA, when C-USA had a contract w/FSN from its inception until 2000. Similar to "ESPN on ABC" and "Golf Channel on NBC", these games will be known as "FOX Sports on F/X" and they'll likely take up the single best of all available games on a weekend.  I'm guessing the majority of these games will be at 7pm, where FSN used to have plenty of preemptions due to regional pro sports.  It likely becomes the regional window for the SEC, Pac-12, ACC (new sublicense from ESPN via Raycom) and C-USA where available.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Big 12, FOX and Revenue

The Big 12 and FOX Sports Media Group and rumored to be close to a new pay tv rights agreement that would pay the conference anywhere between $60 million to $70 million.  My guess is those games will air on FSN affiliates and F/X.  By the movement of Colorado & Nebraska to other conferences, and the existing terms of the deals to remain the same, the Big 12 will gain roughly a 20% increase in revenue per team in 2011-12 without doing anything because ABC and FSN did not change the terms of their existing agreements.  But does the new agreement get the big three of Texas, Oklahoma and Texas A&M close to the number of $20 million in conference distribution?

Depends on how you crunch the numbers.  From a pure TV standpoint, today the Big 12 receives $60 million from ABC/ESPN for football on ABC, which includes the Texas-Texas A&M game if it airs on ESPN, and men’s basketball.  It then receives $19.5 million from FSN for football on FSN, which includes all other football games sublicensed to ESPN, and all other sports (women’s basketball, baseball, etc.).

The Big 12 divides up its TV revenue with an appearance based model. 50% of the money received is distributed to all conference members equally (the conference office might get a cut too). The rest of the money is distributed based on the number of appearances a school makes on TV within the conference’s TV agreements. From one ESPN article, TV appearances in football & men’s basketball are used to determine how to split the other 50%.

Since men’s basketball is included, a school like Kansas, who doesn’t appear on ABC in football as much as Oklahoma or Texas, can make up some ground through men’s basketball. We know that football drives these deals, but how much? If we say football is a base of 1, is men’s basketball .4 (ie. rights for a men’s basketball game are worth 40% of a football game)?

What also needs to be determined is if the existing revenue sharing/appearance fee model will change in any form.  Since the TV money has been equally divided, does that mean that a football game on FSN is now worth approx 3x as much as it is under the existing contract?  If the Big 12 pays $300K for a OOC game on FSN and $150K for a conference game, can we make the leap that the Big 12 will distribute $1 million for an OOC game and $500K for a conference game just to keep the appearance pool revenue at 50% of the FSN contract?  Or at least make changes to the amount that teams receive for playing on ABC?

The numbers make my head dizzy. In short, each of the big three would make slightly more than $12.5 million total from ABC/ESPN and FSN using 2010’s TV appearances in football & men’s basketball, plus the shared revenue from the TV deal.  I also included an “offset” since Nebraska & Colorado made TV appearances in 2010.  That offset was divided equally among the remaining ten teams in my projections, but since the offset is from appearances, it won’t make it to everyone’s bottom line.  I'm also making a boatload of assumptions with my numbers.  Please don't take them as gospel, my statistics background involves a couple courses in college.  But that is roughly a 75% increase in total TV revenue since the ABC deal isn't being reworked, over 300% just from FOX.

So if we’re at $13 million, how can we get to $20 million for these guys? NCAA credits from men’s basketball and bowl payouts then get lumped in. Some of that money is also distributed in favor of the teams who make the tournament and who goes to a bowl game.

In my opinion, its going to be close.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Who's In With Seedings

Here's who I got.  I know that some items could change, but Dayton is the only team that could crash the field.  If Dayton crashes the party, I'll put in a caveat at the bottom.

Here goes...

1 - Ohio St., Kansas, Duke, Pitt
2 - San Diego St., Texas, North Carolina, Notre Dame
3 - Purdue, BYU, Florida, Wisconsin
4 - Kentucky, Syracuse, Louisville, Connecticut
5 - Utah St., Georgetown, West Virginia, Arizona
6 - St. John's, Washington, Kansas St., Cincinnati
7 - George Mason, UNLV, Vanderbilt, Villanova
8 - Illinois, Xavier, Missouri, Temple
9 - Belmont, Texas A&M, Old Dominion, Penn St.
10 - Gonzaga, Clemson, Michigan St., Michigan
11 - Marquette, Richmond, Virginia Tech, Butler
12 - St. Mary's, Tennessee, Florida St./UAB**, UCLA/Georgia**
13 - Oakland, Memphis, Princeton, Bucknell
14 - Morehead St., Long Island, Wofford, Indiana St.
15 - St. Peter's, Northern Colorado, Akron, UC-Santa Barbara
16 - UNC-Asheville, Boston U., Hampton/UALR**, UTSA/Alabama St.**

** - First Four games

If Dayton were to win, slot them between Memphis & Bucknell.  Colorado would be out and the FF games would be Georgia vs. UCLA and UAB vs. Florida St.  Both FF at-large games would be for 12 seeds instead of one for a 12 and one for a 13.

How did I go about this?  Used RealTimeRPI, Sagarin (purple column) and Ken Pomeroy as of this morning, plus I did move a few teams around, but no more than one seed line.

EDIT: Made a late change because I left out Princeton, Ivy League champ.  Colorado gets dumped out because of the switch and both FF at-large games are for 12 seeds.

Friday, March 11, 2011

Pac-12 Football Fridays

The Big East has used Friday for several regular season telecasts, and now the Pac-12 appears to be ready to try it out.  During the week, rumblings appeared that USC-Colorado in early November could be moved to a Friday slot and now we've seen the Missouri-Arizona St. game moved to a Friday evening start. 

In the case of Missouri-Arizona St., there may have been considerations made due to both Arizona schools preferring night games during the 1st month of the season.  The schools want night games due to the extreme temperatures in Arizona at that time of year.  Quite possible that ABC/ESPN wanted the game, but with several choices available for Pac-12 TV partners (Cal-Colorado, Hawai'i-Washington, Utah-USC), its possible that they could not agree on an ideal time for a Saturday game, so moving it to Friday was acceptable, particularly since they could play it in the evening in Tempe after the FIU-Louisville game.

The possible Friday move of USC-Colorado is also interesting.  Friday has been the preferred date among the few fans that have commented about it online and seems to be preferred by the administration due to the congestion around campus due to night classes.  It is still possible that the game could move to Thursday, but ESPN is inquiring about moving the game and a Thursday night game (Florida St.-Boston College) is scheduled for a 8pm start.  So unless it is put on ESPN2, I think Friday is more likely.  Network may be in question for a move to Friday and that may be the opening Friday of the NBA season and the game could be on ESPN2.

So ESPN/ESPN2 Friday schedule looks like this

9/2 - TBA (possibly Marshall-WVU or Wake Forest-Syracuse)
9/9 - FIU-Louisville 7pm ESPN, Missouri-Arizona St. 10:30pm ESPN
9/16 - Iowa St.-Connecticut 8pm ESPN/ESPN2
9/23 - UCF-BYU 8pm ESPN
9/30 - Utah St.-BYU 8pm ESPN
10/7 - TBA (possibly Boise St.-Fresno St.)
10/14 - TBA (possibly a WAC conference game)
10/21 - Rutgers at Louisville 8pm ESPN
10/28 - BYU vs. TCU @Arlington 8pm ESPN
11/4 - TBA (possibly USC-Colorado)
11/11 - USF-Syracuse 8pm ESPN2
11/18 - TBA (possibly WAC or Pac-12 game)
11/25 - Leaving this day alone since it often involves a large schedule of games
12/2 - MAC Championship @Detroit 8pm ESPN2

For Black Friday we know that there likely be a Big East-Big Ten doubleheader on ABC with either Louisville-USF or Pittsburgh-WVU, with the other on ESPN/ESPN2, followed by Iowa-Nebraska.  The WAC has often placed a late evening game here and there been some discussion that ESPN would like a late evening WAC game for that date.

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Big Ten, ABC/ESPN Discussing Contract Changes

Per a report over at the great TV sports website The506.com, the Big Ten and ABC/ESPN are discussing alterations to the existing television contract.  The item specifically being discussed is that ABC's telecast windows will no longer be exclusive, meaning that the Big Ten Network could air games simultaneously as ABC does.  Currently that happens once a year, usually in the final week of the Big Ten schedule.  With Nebraska entering the conference, there will be more games available for all parties and to televise every game, there will need to be some flexibility.  There is some great discussion of what ABC could get from the conference if it were to drop exclusivity:
  • More telecast opportunities for ABC/ESPN.  Currently up to 17 games on ABC, 24 on ESPN/ESPN2.
     
  • Big Ten Network could drop its ability to either
    • Jump ESPN/ESPN2 at times during the season
    • Require all teams to have a conference game on the Big Ten Network
  • Flexibility in selecting games for prime time games
    • I have doubts about this one with many stadiums not having permanent lighting
  • Night games in the month of November
     
  • Possibility for games on non-traditional days during the season, such as Black Friday or Thursday nights
To me, all seem possible except for flexibility in night games due to the lack of lighting at some stadiums.  Bears watching as the offseason and game selections come in.  Typically the Big Ten sets its night games & start times for homecoming games for the season in mid-April.